Ranking albumów Maiden pod względem perełek na danym albumie - Masterclass ranking

[Deleted User 8107]

No to jedziemy, zobaczycie na czym to polega, i mam nadzieję, że dołączycie.

Od najsłabszego do najlepszego:

17-14:

Senjutsu - 0
Book - 0
Amolad - 0
Virtaul XI - 0

13-9:

Jedna perełka:

Killers - (Innocent Exile)
Fear - (Judas)
No Prayer - (Public Enema)
Final - (Starblind)
Iron Maiden - (Strange World)

8 - 6:

Dwie perełki:


Dance of Death - (Paschendale, Face)
The X Factor - (Judgement, Edge)
Brave New World - (Nomad, Thin Line)


5-2:

Trzy perełki:

Number - (Prisoner, Akacja, Number)
Powerslave - (Aces, Tytułowy, Rime)
Piece - (Trooper, Still Life, Tame)
Syn - (Moonchild, Infinite, Evil)

No i miejsce pierwsze:

4 perełki, a chciałem dać jeszcZE Runnera

Sit - (Caught, Wasted, Stranger, Olek)

Czyli nic się nie zmienia, SiT dalej ulubiony album

[pz]

Ale perełka to co? Numer, który uznajesz za wybitny? Wystarczy bardzo dobry? Czy musi być na poziomie DT?

[Deleted User 8107]

Ale perełka to co? Numer, który uznajesz za wybitny? Wystarczy bardzo dobry? Czy musi być na poziomie DT?

Niech będzie wybitny tylko nie wiem, czy tak ogólnie, czy w skali IM.

[Deleted User 626]

No to mi tak wychodzi z pomocą Excela. Ciekawe wnioski

I kawałek:

1. IM - Strange World
2. Killers - Killers
3. NPfTD - Bring...
4. VXI - The Clansman
5. AMOLAD - Benjamin
6. Final Frontier - tylko solo Dave'a w TFF
7. Book of Souls - Red

II kawałki

8. Powerslave - Powerslave i "Rime ..."

III kawałki:

9. Seventh Son - Can I.., Evil, SSotSS
10. XF - MotEdge, Lord, Sign

IV kawałki:

11. PoM - Eagles, Revelations, Trooper, Diuna
12. SiT - Caught, WY, Heaven , Alex
13. BNW - Wicker, Ghost, Brave, Nomad

V Kawałków:

14. NotB - Children, Prisoner, Number, Run, Hallowed
15. DoD - Rain, No more..., DoD, Paschendale, Face
16. Senjutsu - Stratego, Time Machine, Darkest, Parchement, Hell

VI kawałków:

17. FotD - Be Quick, Hell.., Afraid, Weekend, Judas, Fear.


Gratuluję tematu. Sam bym się nie spodziewał.

[Cold]

Wybitnie subiektywny wybór w wybitnie subiektywnej ankiecie.

17. The Final Frontier (1 - The Talisman)
16. Virtual XI (1 - The Clansman)
15. No Prayer For The Dying (1 - Public Enema Number One)
14. Killers (1 - Killers)
13. Iron Maiden (1 - Phantom of the Opera)
12. The Book Of Souls (2 - If Eternity Should Fail, The Book of Souls)
11. The X Factor (2 - Sign of the Cross, Judgement of Heaven)
10. Dance of Death (2 - Dance of Death, Paschendale)
9. Somewhere In Time (2 - Wasted Years, Alexander the Great)
8. Fear Of The Dark (3 - Be Quick or Be Dead, Childhood's End, Fear of the Dark)
7. A Matter of Life and Death (3 - These Colours Don't Run, For the Greater Good of God, The Legacy)
6. Senjutsu (3 - Senjutsu, The Parchment, Hell on Earth)
5. Brave New World (3 - Ghost of the Navigator, The Nomad, The Thin Line Between Love and Hate)
4. Piece Of Mind (3 - Where Eagles Dare, Flight of Icarus, To Tame a Land)
3. The Number Of The Beast (3 - Children of the Damned, The Number of the Beast, Hallowed Be Thy Name)
2. Powerslave (4 - Aces High, The Duellists, Powerslave, Rime of the Ancient Marine)
1. Seventh Son Of A Seventh Son (4 - Infinite Dreams, The Evil That Men Do, Seventh Son of a Seventh Son, The Prophecy)

[remi]

17. No Prayer (0)
16. Virtual XI (1 - The Clansman)
15. Killers (1 - Wrathchild)
Album Killers z tej grupy najlepszy (jako LP jako całość)

14. Iron Maiden (2 - Remember Tomorrow, Phantom of the Opera)
13. Fear of the Dark (2 - Fear of the Dark i Be Quick or Be Dead)
12. The Final Frontier (2 - The Talisman i When The Wild Wind Blows)
11. The Book Of Souls (2 - Empire of the Clouds, The Book of Souls)
10. The X Factor (2 - Sign of the Cross, The Edge of Darkness)
9. Dance of Death (2 - Dance of Death, Paschendale)
8. A Matter of Life and Death (2 - The Longest Day, For the Greater Good of God)
AMOLAD I DOD z tej grupy najlepsze (jako LP jako całość)

7. The Number Of The Beast (3 - Run to the Hills, The Number of the Beast, Hallowed Be Thy Name)
6. Piece Of Mind (3 - Revelations, Flight of Icarus, The Trooper)
POM lepszy w tej grupie (jako LP jako całość)

5. Powerslave (4 - Aces High, 2 Minutes to Midnight, Powerslave, Rime of the Ancient Marine)
4. Senjutsu (4 - Senjutsu, WOTW, The Parchment, Hell on Earth)
3. Somewhere In Time (4 - Caught SIT, Wasted Years, Stranger in a Strange Land, Alexander the Great)
SiT>Senjutsu>Powerslave (jako LP jako całość)

2. Seventh Son Of A Seventh Son (5 - Infinite Dreams, The Evil That Men Do, Seventh Son of a Seventh Son, The Prophecy, Only the Good Die Young)
1. Brave New World (6 - Wicker Man, Ghost of the Navigator, The Nomad, Blood Brothers, Dream of Mirrors, The Thin Line Between Love and Hate)
Tutaj remis albumy nr 1 ery przed i po reunion.

[Piotr Lange]

17. No Prayer (0)
16. Virtual XI (1 - The Clansman)
15. Killers (1 - Wrathchild)
Album Killers z tej grupy najlepszy (jako LP jako całość)

14. Iron Maiden (2 - Remember Tomorrow, Phantom of the Opera)
13. Fear of the Dark (2 - Fear of the Dark i Be Quick or Be Dead)
12. The Final Frontier (2 - The Talisman i When The Wild Wind Blows)
11. The Book Of Souls (2 - Empire of the Clouds, The Book of Souls)
10. The X Factor (2 - Sign of the Cross, The Edge of Darkness)
9. Dance of Death (2 - Dance of Death, Paschendale)
8. A Matter of Life and Death (2 - The Longest Day, For the Greater Good of God)
AMOLAD I DOD z tej grupy najlepsze (jako LP jako całość)

7. The Number Of The Beast (3 - Run to the Hills, The Number of the Beast, Hallowed Be Thy Name)
6. Piece Of Mind (3 - Revelations, Flight of Icarus, The Trooper)
POM lepszy w tej grupie (jako LP jako całość)

5. Powerslave (4 - Aces High, 2 Minutes to Midnight, Powerslave, Rime of the Ancient Marine)
4. Senjutsu (4 - Senjutsu, WOTW, The Parchment, Hell on Earth)
3. Somewhere In Time (4 - Caught SIT, Wasted Years, Stranger in a Strange Land, Alexander the Great)
SiT>Senjutsu>Powerslave (jako LP jako całość)

2. Seventh Son Of A Seventh Son (5 - Infinite Dreams, The Evil That Men Do, Seventh Son of a Seventh Son, The Prophecy, Only the Good Die Young)
1. Brave New World (6 - Wicker Man, Ghost of the Navigator, The Nomad, Blood Brothers, Dream of Mirrors, The Thin Line Between Love and Hate)
Tutaj remis albumy nr 1 ery przed i po reunion.

Mamy zbliżony gust, u mnie jedynie Senjutsu byłby za TNOTB a The Book of Souls wyżej.

[Geri666]

17. The Book Of Souls (1 - The Book of Souls)
16. Killers (1 - Killers)
15. A Matter of Life and Death (1 - The Legacy)

14. Iron Maiden (2 - Phantom of the Opera, Strange World)
13. The Final Frontier (2 - The Talisman, WTWWB)
12. No Prayer For The Dying (2 - NPFTD, Public Enema Number One)
11. Dance of Death (2 - Dance of Death, Paschendale)
10. Brave New World (2 - Out Of The Silent planet, The Thin Line Between Love and Hate)
9. The Number Of The Beast (2 - Children of the Damned, Hallowed Be Thy Name)
8. Seventh Son Of A Seventh Son (2 - Infinite Dreams, The Evil That Men Do)
7. Senjutsu (2 - TWOTW, Hell on Earth)


6. Virtual XI (3 - The Clansman, WTWC, Futureal)
5. Somewhere In Time (3 - Wasted Years, loneliness of a long distance runner, Alexander the Great)
4. Powerslave (3 - Aces High, TMTM, Powerslave)

3. Piece Of Mind (4 - Where Eagles Dare, Revelations, Flight of Icarus, To Tame a Land)

2. Fear Of The Dark (6 - Be Quick or Be Dead, Childhood's End, Afraid, Judas Be My Guide, Wasting Love, Fear of the Dark)
1. The X Factor (6 - Sign of the Cross, Lord Of The Flies, Judgement of Heaven, Edge Of Darkness, Fortunes Of War, 2AM)


ciekawa zabawa. Zupełnie inaczej trzeba patrzeć na albumy Ranking przekrojowy inaczej by wyglądał

[Deleted User 8011]

17. Iron Maiden (1 - Phantom of the Opera )
16. Killers ( 1 - Killers)
15.AMOLAD (1 - Reincarnation of Bejnamin Breeg)

14. The Number of The Beast (2 - Hallowed, Children of the Damned)
13 The X Factor - (2 - Sign of the Cross, Lord Of The Flies)
12. Brave New World (2 - Out of the Silent Planet, The Nomad)
11. Piece of Mind ( 2 - Where Eagles Dare, To Tame a Land)
10. Dance of Death (2 - Dance of Death, Paschendale)
9. Virtual XI (1 - The Clansman)
8. No Prayer for the Dying (2 - Tailgunner, No Prayer for the Dying)
7. Fear Of The Dark ( 2 - Be Quick or Be Dead, Judas Be My Guide)

6. The Final Frontier (3 - When The Wild Wind Blows, The Talisman, The Man Who Would Be King)
5 .Senjutsu (3 - The Writing on the Wall, The Parchment, Hell on Earth)
4. The Book of Souls - ( 3 The Book of Souls, Empire of the Cloud, If Eternity Should Fail)
3. Powerslave - ( 3- Aces High, Powerslave, Rime of the Ancient Mariner)
2. Somewhere In Time ( 3 - Caught Somewhere in Time, Stranger in a Strange Land, The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner)

1. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son ( 4- Moonchild, Seventh Son of a Seventh Son, The Prophecy, Infinite Dreams)

[krusejder]

Bardzo mi ta klasyfikacja spłaszczyła płyty Maiden. Wciąż wolę SIT od Powerslave

1998 VE - 1 - Clansman
2010 FF - 1 - When the Wild Wind Blows

1980 IM - 2 - Phantom of the Opera, Transylvania
1981 Ki - 2 - Murders in the Rue Morgue, Twilight Zone
1988 SS - 2 - Infinite Dreams, Prophecy
1990 NP - 2 - No Prayer for the Dying, Bring Your Daughter
1995 XF - 2 - Sign of the Cross, Edge of Darkness
2003 DD - 2 - Dance of Death, Paschendale
2015 BS - 2 - If Eternity Should Fall, Empire of the Clouds
2021 S - 2 - Parchment, Hell on Earth

1982 Nr - 3 - Prisoner, 22 Acacia Av, Hallowed
1983 PM - 3 - Revelations, Trooper, Quest for Fire
1986 ST - 3 - Caught Somewhere, Stranger in a Strange, Alexander
1992 FD - 3 - Be Quick, Afraid to Shoot Strangers, Fear of the Dark
2000 BW - 3 - Wicker Man, Blood Brothers, Fallen Angel
2006 AM - 3 - These Colours Dont Run, For the Greater Good of God, Legacy

1984 PS - 4 - Aces High, Duellists, Powerslave, Rime

[Journeyman666]

0:
17. Killers
16. Iron Maiden

1:
15. A Matter of Life and Death - The Longest Day
14. No Prayer for the Dying - Holy Smoke

2:
13. The Book of Souls - If Eternity Should Fail, The Book of Souls
12. Virtual XI - The Clansman, Como Estais Amigos
11. Somewhere in Time - Wasted Years, Alexander the Great
10. Piece of Mind - The Trooper, To Tame a Land
9. The Final Frontier - The Alchemist, When the Wild Wind Blows
8. The Number of the Beast - Run to the Hills, The Number of the Beast

3:
7. The X Factor - Sign of the Cross, Judgement of Heaven, The Edge of Darkness
6. Fear of the Dark - Judas Be My Guide, Afraid to Shoot Strangers, Fear of the Dark
5. Powerslave - 2 Minutes to Midnight, Aces High, Powerslave

4:
4. Senjutsu - Stratego, The Writing on the Wall, The Parchment, Hell on Earth
3. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son - Infinite Dreams, The Evil that Men Do, Seventh Son of a Seventh Son, , Only the Good Die Young
2. Dance of Death - Montsegur, Dance of Death, Paschendale, Journeyman

5:
1. Brave New World - The Wicker Man, Ghost of the Navigator, Brave New World, Blood Brothers, The Thin Line Between Love and Hate

[ÓsmyUtwórNaBNW]

0
Senjutsu, Book of Souls

1
AMOLAD ( Reincarnation of Benjamin Breeg)

Final Frontier (Isle of Avalon)

No Prayer for the Dying ( Run Silent Run Deep)

2
Iron Maiden (Prowler, Phantom of the Opera)

Fear of the Dark (Be Quick or Be Dead, Childhood's End)

Virtual XI (Futureal, Clansman)

X Factor (Sign of the Cross, Lord of the Flies)

3
Dance of Death( Dance of Death, Paschendale, Face in the Sand)

Brave New World (Ghost of Navigator, Nomad, tytułowy)

Killers ( Killers, Prodigal Son, Murders in the Rue Mourge)

4
Number of the Beast ( Prisoner, 22 Acacia Avenue, tytułowy, Hallowed Be thy Name)

5
Powerslave ( Aces High, Two Minutes to Midnight, Duellists, Powerslave, Rime of the Ancient Mariner)

Somewhere in Time ( Caught Somewhere in Time, Sea of Madness, Loneliness of Long Distance Runner, Stranger in the Strange Land, Alexander the Great)

7th Son of a 7th Son ( Moonchild, Infinite Dreams, Clairvoyant, tytułowy, Prophecy)

7
Piece of Mind (Where Eagles Dare, Revelations, Flight of Icarus, Die With Your Boots On, The Trooper, Still Life, To Tame a Land)

Oprócz tego dam listę płyt wg. utworów których nie lubię

0

Seventh Son of a Seventh Son
Piece of Mind
Somewhere in Time
Killers
Iron Maiden

1

Number of the Beast- Run to the Hills
Brave New World- Blood Brothers
Dance of Death- Journeyman
Powerslave- Losfer Words

2

Fear of the Dark- Apparition, Weekend Warrior
No Prayer for the Dying- Bring Your Daughter to the Slaughter, Mother Russia
Virtual XI- Angel and the Gambler, Don't Look to the Eyes of a Stranger
X Factor (Look for the Truth, 2 am.

3

AMOLAD ( Different World, Out of the Shadows, Brighter than a 1000 Suns)
Book of Souls, (Tears of a Clown, Man of Sorrows, Death or Glory)


4

Final Frontier (Alchemist, Man Who Would Be a King, El Dorado, Coming Home)

7

Senjutsu (wszystko poza Parchment, Stratego i Days of Future Past)




Iron Maiden 2-0
Killers 3-0
Number 4-1
Piece of Mind 7-0
Powerslave 5-1
Somewhere in Time 5-0
7th Son 5-0
No Prayer 1-2
Fear 2-2
X Factor 2-2
Virtual 2-2
Brave 3-1
Dance 3-1
AMOLAD 1-3
Frontier 1-4
Book of Souls 0-3
Senjutsu 0-7

[Deleted User 8263]

0:
No Prayer, Killers, Book of Souls, Fear
1:
BNW (Ghost), Iron Maiden (Phantom), Senjutsu (HoE), AMOLAD (FTGGOG), X Factor (Sign), Dance of Death (Face in the Sand)

2:
Number (Hallowed, 22), Peace (To Tame, Eagles), Virtual (Fool, Clansman)

3:
Powerslave (Aces, Rime, Powerslave),

4:
SiT (Caught, Loneliness, Sea, Alexander),

5:
Syn (Moonchild, Evil, Tytułowy, Clairvoyant, Only), Frontier (Alchemist, Avalon, Talisman, King, Wind)

[TV WAR]

Chyba do tego tematu najbardziej pasuje. Top 3 z (prawie) każdej płyty, z dwoma wyjątkami

Iron Maiden

1.Phantom of the Opera
2.Prowler
3.Transylvania

Killers

1.Killers
2.Prodigal Son
3.Murders in the Rue Mourge

The Number of the Beast

1.Hallowed Be thy Name
2.The Prisoner
3.The Number of the Beast

Piece of Mind

1.Where Eagles Dare
2.Flight of Icarus
3.To Tame a Land
4.Revelations

Powerslave

1.Rime of the Ancient Mariner
2.Powerslave
3.Aces High

Somewhere in Time

1.Caught Somewhere in Time
2.Sea of Madness
3.Alexander the Great
4.Stranger in the Strange Land

7th Son of a 7th Son

1.Infinite Dreams
2.The Clairvoyant
3.7th Son of a 7th Son

No Prayer for Dying

1.Run Silent Run Deep
2.Fates Warning
3.Tailgunner

Fear of the Dark

1.Childhood's End
2.Be Quick or Be Dead
3.The Fugitive

X Factor

1.Sign of the Cross
2.Lord of the Flies
3.Blood on the World's Hands

Virtual XI

1.Futureal
2.Clansman
3.Como Estais Amigos

Brave New World

1.Ghost of Navigator
2.Brave New World
3.Nomad

Dance of Death

1.Dance of Death
2.Face in the Sand
3.New Frontier

AMOLAD

1.Reincarnation of Benjamin Breeg
2.These Colours Don't Run
3.The Pilgrim

Final Frontier

1.Isle of Avalon
2.The Talisman
3.Mother of Mercy

Book of Souls

1.When the Rivers Run Deep
2.Book of Souls
3.brak, żaden nie spełnia minimalnych warunków

Senjutsu

1.The Parchment
2.brak, żaden nie spełnia minimalnych warunków
3.jak wyżej

[sajki]

Iron Maiden

1.Phantom of the Opera
2.Prowler
3. Remember Tomorrow

Killers

1.Killers
2.Purgatory
3.Murders in the Rue Mourge

The Number of the Beast

1.Hallowed Be thy Name
2.Run to the Hills
3.Invaders

Piece of Mind

1.Where Eagles Dare
2.Flight of Icarus
3.To Tame a Land

Powerslave

1.Two Minutes to Midnight
2.Powerslave
3.Aces High

Somewhere in Time

1.Caught Somewhere in Time
2.Alexander the Great
3.Stranger in the Strange Land

7th Son of a 7th Son

1.Infinite Dreams
2.The Evil that Men Do
3.Only the Good Die Young

No Prayer for Dying

1.Run Silent Run Deep
2.Bring Your Daughter
3.Tailgunner

Fear of the Dark

1.Afraid
2.Be Quick or Be Dead
3.Judad Be My Guide

X Factor

1.Sign of the Cross
2.Lord of the Flies
3.Fortunes of War

Virtual XI

1.Futureal
2.Clansman
3.When Two Worlds Collide

Brave New World

1.Ghost of Navigator
2.The Wicker Man
3.Fallen Angel

Dance of Death

1.Rainmaker
2.Face in the Sand
3.Paschendale

AMOLAD

1.Lord of Light
2.These Colours Don't Run
3.FTGGOG

Final Frontier

1.Starblind
2.The Talisman
3. Alchemist

Book of Souls

1.If Eternity Should Fail
2.Book of Souls
3.Shadows of the Valley

Senjutsu

1.Stratego
2.Writing on the Wall
3.Darkest Hour

Kolejność utworów przypadkowa. Najtrudniej było wybrać aż trzy kompozycje z trzech ostatnich płyt.

[TV WAR]

Dlatego się poddałem. Z Final Frontier jeszcze jakoś wyszło, dwa ostatnie odpuściłem. Book of Souls to jedna z najmniej ciekawych płyt jakie znam (powiedzmy, tych wielkich zespołów). Wszystko na tym albumie jest równe w przeciętności. Nie ma co prawda jakiegoś arcysłabego utworu, ale nie ma też momentów. Czegoś co by powodowało, że chce się do tego wracać. Do tego dochodzą koszmarne, bardzo czytelne błędy produkcyjne. Wszystko brzmi tak strasznie wolno. To mógł być niezły album, ale jak się tak podchodzi do nagrywania - to nie ma co się dziwić.

[TV WAR]

Honor Mentions 15 kawałków spoza mojego zestawienia...10 nie dałem rady

Genghis Khan
Another Life
22 Acacia Avenue
Invaders
Trooper
Die With Your Boots On
The Duellists
Two Minutes to Midnight
Loneliness of Long Distance Runner
The Prophecy
Moonchild
Edge of Darkness
The Mercenary
Rainmaker